Those that know me will recognise that I am my no means an
eco-warrior. I love cars, motorways, air
travel and all the conveniences and luxuries of modern life too much to really
have any credibility as a true eco-warrior.
Yet that doesn’t mean I don’t care about the environment in
which we live.
I am now going to start a rant – so be warned this blog
entry is long and fiery and I hope it motivates people to enter into some form
of debate here in sleepy Andalucia.
My attitude to the environment as changed since I began my new life in Spain. It probably sounds inconsistent, but since the environment here is so
different for me, somehow exotic, I notice more the impact of its destruction. Seeing
a lush green field in England turned into a supermarket didn’t really have much
resonance for me – well, there are plenty of fields, right? I realised how
flawed that argument was when I moved here. I could see the exceptional speed
with which land is eaten by construction every year, with little thought about
planning, architecture, sustainability or aesthetics.Andalucia, I believe is an interesting case study for challenges
to control the impact of urbanisation. Firstly, historically it has been the one of the poorest parts Spain, so
welcomes development and the jobs and wealth they create with open arms. Secondly, the area, sadly, is less
sophisticated in terms of social democratic structures, so the autonomous
government, the local town halls, the judicial system and the independent
tribunals etc, are all somewhat badly run, ineffective and prone to corruption.
In a country with a young democracy, there are few effective checks and
balances. Thirdly, you have a population
of relaxed, laid back Andalucians that really don’t like conflict – when things
go wrong, they are more willing to accept it than to challenge it. In the UK, when
things go wrong, it mobilises debate in the media, amongst individuals in the
pub and sometimes brings people out onto the street. That’s not often the case here.That’s why the operation here in Marbella against corruption
is so interesting and so important. It
shows that the tide is turning against the madness in construction in Southern
Spain. Marbella is a beautiful part of
the world and the environmental cost of the corruption in urban planning is not
as bad as it could have been. Hotels,
office blocks and homes have been built illegally with the support of the
former corrupt town hall, accepting exceptional amounts of bribes from
developers and land owners, together with the complicit support of the regional
government, the Junta de Andalucia. Yet luckily the city still remains a
beautiful place.
However, across the coast in just the few years I have lived
here, I have seen the price of the appalling mess in Andalucian town planning. My favourite beach in Cadiz province,
Bolonia, near Tarifa, with its stunning Roman ruins spill down onto the broad
golden beaches, has been scarred by a huge concrete bunker that the Junta de Andalucía
wanted as a “visitor centre”. Nothing
was done to stop it. Then over time, the
surfing community, the locals and the foreigners that loved the area mobilised
popular opinion against it. President Chavas of Andalucia finally agreed to
halt construction, but now this ugly, half finished hulk just lies dead amongst
the sand dunes of Bolonia. The same is true of another half finished, illegal
“visitor centre” amongst the ancient pines on the road from the Med up to
Ronda. What madness?!
Closer to home, in Manilva the ancient vineyards that date
back to Roman times have been butchered by the construction of illegal luxury
holiday homes. Luckily, here too the corruption
has been uncovered and construction stopped. In fact some of the homes are been
knocked down as a signal to developers and investors that things much change; but
this was only possible since the homes were not sold. Once foreigners have bought the holiday
homes, it is almost impossible for the land to be recovered, as the impact on
the holiday home market would be immense if people were to start to lose their
homes without adequate compensation.For me the most depressing example so far of the madness in
planning here is in the natural park of Cabo de Gata in Almeria.
Yesterday we
came back from Almeria, where we are spending more time, as Rafa is working
there once a week. We explored more of the stunning Costa de Almeria, with its
unique Cabo de Gata Natural Park. Yet,
as we drove south through stunning scenery we were abruptly greeted by a huge
concrete pyramid – a structure of over 20 stories high, starting from less that
50 metres from the beach, climbing right up the mountainside. This was a huge hotel under construction,
within the natural park!
Can Spain really be trusted with its Mediterranean
coastline? As members of the European
Union, this is a part of Europe. This
stunning coast is unique in the entire Mediterranean, and should be protected
for all to enjoy – yet here was see a monstrous structure, blatantly contrary
to all planning laws.
I was in shock. I wanted to find out more. There is little public debate about these
issues here in Andalucia. People have worked and lived on the land and for
most, it is just a resource. Just as say
a former Rover car worker probably has little nostalgia or feeling for the old Longbridge
factory in Birmingham. It’s just a work place – nothing more.
I believe though, that the countryside has to be afforded
some protection. There is enough space
in Andalucia to easily accommodate the huge demand for holiday homes, hotels
and new communities – it just has to be zoned. Somehow people have to be educated that the land, once destroyed, cannot
be restored. Unlike a historic factory or
mill that has fallen into disrepair, a carved up mountain side can never be
restored to its former glory.
The huge hotel in the Cabo de Gata Natural Park is called
“Algarrobico” and is slowly becoming the symbol of the fight here in Spain
against corruption in town planning. “Amigos del parque natural de Cabo de
Gata” are an eco group that has taken the battle to Europe. The local town halls and the Junta de
Andalucia are so corrupt and out of control, that Brussels is now looking at
the issue.
“La corrupcion urbanistica empieza a manchar la imagen de
Espana”, reads the first line of a report in the group’s newsletter. Basically,
the Friends of the Natural Park are highlighting how Spain’s image in Europe is
being stained through the illegitimacy of its town halls. International bodies
such as Transparency International see that corruption in Spain’s town halls
and especially those in Andalucía is almost out of control. Democracy is young here and the generation
that lived off the land and lived under Franco are still alive. So the challenges
to build a transparent and accountable regional and local government system are
hard. Transforming poor communities
through cheap, profitable construction is far more seductive.
The illiterate, unemployed and disenfranchised in the
country villages of Andalucia seem unable to comprehend the negative impact of the
Junta de Andalusia’s flawed policies - or at least seem powerless to stop it.. Andalucia
still has some amazing natural and cultural heritage that attracts high net
worth tourists that are essential to the region's diversification away from the
kiss-me-quick holiday makers that come to eat egg and chips in the sun.
Wake up Andalucia, or soon it will be too late!
If like me you want to do something about this – then make a
donation to the Friends of Cabo de Gata Natural Park, by visiting their website
at www.cabodegata.net
(newspaper clippings image taken from www.cabodegata.net site)